I have a friend who is, for lack of a better term, a real free spirit. Now, how you interpret that word will be largely based on your experience of free-spirited folks, and for my friend and I, it was fun and interesting –until she had a baby. Not that her free-spirited nature was a problem, no, that wasn’t it; the problem was that her son is the product of a free-spirited full-time mom.
Initially, no one really cared how Sylvie (not her real name) looked after Will. She seemed to be following her gut, and for a long time it worked just fine. Will appeared to be completely happy and healthy, proof that regular meals and naps and a bedtime weren’t the answer for everyone. We’d watch him toddle around barbecues with his handful of crackers, engaging delightfully with everyone, and think, so what if he has never had a meal? Over time, little complaints started to seep out of Sylvie, though. Slowly we learned how exhausted she was, that she spent the entire weekend sleeping when her mother could cover Will. Will had never slept in his crib, he slept with her, on the floor, and kept her awake all night with kicking and multiple requests for juice. He never napped, and crashed at any given time after ten at night. This little boy is now five, and has never slept through the night, only eats crackers and, every time I see him now, is in full-blown tantrum mode.
Oh, there it is, can you feel it? Can you feel the judgement? The head-shaking, tsk-tsking creeping in? I have, for years, every time I saw Sylvie and Will. When she would have to ask one of us to put him in his car seat. When she had to borrow diapers or juice or some money because she never had anything with her. It was so easy –and so wrong –to feel superior to Sylvie, but we did, all of us, when we talked about her and wondered how long before she could come to her senses. None of us wanted to insult her choices by making suggestions, so we sat by and watched her All the things we loved about Sylvie were getting drowned out by Will’s increasing tantrums and his possessiveness of her. I know I began to wonder if I really wanted to spend my precious free time listening to Will lose it once again.
And then one day, Sylvie showed up early for a get-together. Will bolted out of the car as usual and tore around the yard. She’d clearly been crying, and before I could even ask what the matter was, she threw her hands up and blurted out. “Help me. I have no idea what I am doing. I can’t parent myself, nevermind that one.”
“Oh, Sylvie,” I tried to hug her but she was too far gone.”That’s the thing, someone does have to be in charge.”
“I hate being in charge.”
“I know. But it’s not forever.” I treaded carefully. “You know, your life would be a lot easier if you made a couple of changes. Just structure your days a little.”
She broke down again. “People keep telling me that, like I actually know what that means.”
And that’s when it hit me. She hadn’t structured or disciplined anything in Will’s life not because she didn’t want to, but because she didn’t know how. She was from a family of bohemian free–thinkers who had been supported by her grandfather’s genius.They had never been troubled by practical concerns like routines or holding down a job. Asking her to structure Will’s day was like handing her a physics problem when she had no idea what math was.
We stood and watched Will throw pebbles at my car. “Will you help me?” she said.
“I can only tell you what works for me.” I said. ‘it’s not like I have the patent on parenting or anything.”
“Please.”
“Okay. Do you think he should be throwing pebbles at my car?”
She shrugged.
“That would be a ‘no’ for me. Why don’t you start by taking a deep breath and tell Will to knock it off.”
“Will, sweetie, don’t do that, baby,’ she crooned. Will ignored her.
“Sylvie? You want my help, right?”
“Yes.”
“Try this.” I took a breath. “KNOCK IT OFF, WILL! ” Startled, Will stopped, his arm cranked back, and stared at me. I looked at Sylvie and she smiled, the tiniest of smiles.
“You okay?’
“Yeah.”
