I’m 42 and had my first mammogram this year. At my annual exam, my gynecologist didn’t hesitate to recommend it (and scold me for not having done it sooner), because yearly mammograms for women over 40 have been the standard since at least 2002. Yesterday, the panel that created that standard, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, announced a change. It no longer recommends routine mammograms at all for women under age 50.
That announcement touched off a heated debate, and the two sides fall into line something like this:
The task force and those who support its recommendation say women in their 40s are at very low risk of breast cancer, and that their risk from unnecessary biopsies due to false-positive mammograms outweighs the early-detection benefits of the mammograms themselves.
Those opposed to the change, including the American College of Radiology, say that women in their 40s account for 25% of all breast cancer diagnoses, and that their cancers are often the aggressive type. Removing mammography as an early-detection tool, they say, would reverse the progress that has been made over the past 20 years and increase deaths from breast cancer.
I haven’t seen enough evidence to tip me firmly toward either side of the debate, but one aspect of the USPSTF guideline change does bother me. Usually a guideline is just that, and doesn’t force your hand either way. But because insurance companies tend to cover procedures and screenings recommended by the task force – and not to cover those the task force doesn’t recommend – they could be making decisions for millions of women.
Which means that next year, my doctor and I might not be deciding whether I have a mammogram. My insurance company might already have taken care of that.
Read the Annals of Internal Medicine article with the task force recommendation …
Read the American College of Radiology statement against it …

Don’t forget to tune in tomorrow (Tuesday, November 17) or set your DVRs for The Doctors! In this special episode, Oscar the Grouch, Zoe, and some of their pals from Sesame Street turn up to talk with kid members of the studio audience –and kids and families at home — about “eating the rainbow,” the proper treatment of boogers, and other ways to stay healthy. I was at the taping, and can tell you it’s a great opportunity to have fun watching with your children, and learn something to boot!
I’ll bet you parents remember Casper. He’s still around (he turns 60 this year!), but Halloween has changed a bit since your last trick-or-treat. Here are some updated safety rules from the Friendly Ghost himself (with help from an expert or two):
Many parents don’t realize that a child’s eyes are actually more fragile in many ways than an adult’s, because the visual system continues to develop immediately after birth, and some parts of the eye and visual system can continue to change throughout childhood. Throughout childhood, it is not uncommon for a child to suffer an infection, allergic reaction or decreased vision.
Turn off the TV and send your kids outside to play. That’s the advice to parents from the author of a new study that found seven of every 10 kids in the U.S. have low levels of vitamin D. The study, in the Aug. 3 online edition of Pediatrics,
Women who currently take or have taken hormone therapy (HT) after menopause – no matter what dose, formulation, or length of use – have increased risk of ovarian cancer, according to an article in today’s issue of JAMA.
Women who suffer from the awful pain of migraine headaches could have one small consolation: as much as 30% less risk of breast cancer, according to two separate studies involving 11,000 women total. Why? Probably because of estrogen. Lower levels are associated with migraines, while higher levels are associated with increased risk of breast cancer. Another potential factor, said study author Dr. Christopher I. Li and colleagues from Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle, is that women with migraines tend to use more NSAID pain killers, such as ibuprofen and naproxen.
I’ve had more than one health expert tell me that the best way to keep your family hydrated is to have reusable stainless steel water bottles on hand – filled with filtered water from your tap. This is the time of year when most local water suppliers issue something called a Consumer Confidence Report (CCR), which they’ve been required to do by the EPA since 1998. (You should get one in the mail, or be able to find it online. If not, call your water company to request a copy.)
With school out and the sun blazing, every kid who can is ready to hit the road – to the beach, their summer job, a friend’s pool party, or just for a drive. And data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration show that with all this extra driving comes a spike in summer accidents among young people.
